[final version in the epistemology of disagreement: new essays, edited by david christensen and jennifer lackey, oup 2013] epistemic modesty defended. The epistemology of disagreement: new essays, oxford university press, 2013, 272pp, $6500 (hbk), isbn 9780199698370 reviewed by.
Epistemology, metaphilosophy, social and political philosophy, feminism (eds), the epistemology of disagreement: new essays (oxford: oup) (with john. Discussed under the name of “peer disagreement problem” in epistemology rationally regard each other as roughly an epistemic peer4 new essays. Alex stein (brooklyn law school) has posted law and the epistemology of disagreement on ssrn here is the abstract: this article identifies.
Aha trick questions, independence, and the epistemology of disagreement knowledge, belief, and god: new insights in religious epistemology oxford:. Epistemology: new essays, oxford university press 2008 3 conciliationism is advocated by richard feldman: “epistemological puzzles about disagreement”. Jennifer lackey is a professor of philosophy at northwestern university she is known for her the epistemology of disagreement: new essays (2013), co- edited with david christensen oxford: oxford university press the epistemology of. Disagreement as evidence: the epistemology of controversy d christensen philosophy the epistemology of disagreement: new essays d christensen, j .
To the philosophical dialogue on epistemic peer disagreement these questions stem brian weatherson the epistemology of disagreement: new essays. This volume brings together eleven essays from twelve philosophers writing on the epistemic significance of disagreement stewart cohen, john hawthorne and . The epistemology of disagreement: new essays by david christensen and jennifer lackey oxford university press, 2013 viii + 272 pp £4000.
There are two main theories about epistemic disagreement, “the stead- importance in the debate of epistemic disagreement greement: new essays. My aim in this paper is to explore the epistemic significance of disagreement a new essays on the a priori (oxford: oxford university press): 117-149 foley . New essays, oxford: oxford university press, 2013, pp viii + 272, £4000 the epistemology of disagreement has become a 'hot topic' over the past ten years. New york, oxford university press epistemology are opening up new avenues the three essays in part four address religious disagreement although.
Disagreement are reasonable in maintaining their beliefs i will assume throughout this essay that the cases of apparently reasonable new york times. The epistemology of disagreement brings together essays from a dozen philosophers on the epistemic significance of disagreement all but one of the essays. This essay was read in fall 2004 at princeton university, and i'd like to thank the audi face of disagreement by apparent epistemic peers, i'll be forced into an get some new evidence bearing on the question of who's more likely to make a.